- Strategy Wars
- Posts
- Pay to Play? The Truth About Paid vs. Organic Growth in 2025
Pay to Play? The Truth About Paid vs. Organic Growth in 2025
If you had to bet your entire marketing budget on one strategy — paid ads or organic traffic... which one would you choose?
Stephen Hilgart
March 08, 2025
📜 WAR BRIEFING
Want Eyeballs on Your Business? Pay Up or Play the Long Game
Advertising isn’t what it used to be. Prices are surging, competition is fierce, and organic reach…?
Well… let’s just say the “free” route isn’t exactly free anymore.
This week I dug deep into the latest reports from HubSpot, Meta, Google, TikTok, and more to uncover the real numbers behind Paid vs. Organic marketing in 2025 — and what they mean for your business.
Whether you’re running ads or playing the long game with organic, you need to know the costs, risks, and what’s actually working right now.
Inside This Battle Report:
🟢 The State of Paid Advertising – What’s working, what’s not, and the rising costs across platforms.
🔴 The State of Organic Marketing – Can you still get reach without spending a dime?
📊 The Real Cost Breakdown – Cost per lead, cost per sale, and what to expect based on platform.
⏳ What It Takes to Win Organically – How much time, effort, and content does it actually take?
Let’s dive in.
This one is packed with hard data you can’t afford to miss.
📡 A MESSAGE FROM OUR ALLIES
Start, Run & Scale Your Business — From Anywhere
Whether you just bankrupted a billion-dollar auto brand or are starting your first business — you need a solid foundation.
🚀 Business Anywhere makes it effortless:
✔ Form your company in minutes.
✔ Get a professional business address.
✔ Manage everything remotely—without the paperwork headache.
💡 Entrepreneurs go global. We make it simple.
🔗 Get Started Today
📊 INTEL REPORT
Marketing Economics: What It Actually Costs to Get Clicks, Calls & Cash in 2025
Warning: marketing math ahead may hurt brain (it did mine).
⚠️ Proceed with caution. ⚠️
1️⃣ The State of Paid Advertising in 2025 (Costs Are Up. Effectiveness? That Depends.)
Paid ads are more expensive than ever. The average cost-per-click (CPC) across industries rose by 17% last year and is expected to continue climbing.
The days of easy Facebook ad arbitrage are over. The average CPM (cost per 1,000 impressions) on Meta is now $14.90, up from $11.54.
Google Ads? CPC is up 9% YoY, and cost per lead is rising across industries.
TikTok Ads are still underpriced, but competition is heating up, and new regulations could change the landscape.
Programmatic ad spending is expected to reach $626B globally in 2025, but fraud, ad fatigue, and tracking limitations (post-iOS14) make it harder to drive real results.
Bottom Line: Paid advertising is still powerful, but rising costs demand better funnels, stronger offers, and more strategic execution to stay profitable.
2️⃣ The State of Organic Marketing in 2025 (More Competitive Than Ever, But Still Viable.)
Organic reach is shrinking — platforms want businesses to pay.
Facebook organic reach is down to 2.2% per post.
Instagram reach is 9.3% (but dropping).
TikTok still has strong reach (~30%), but saturation is increasing.
SEO is evolving — search traffic is declining as AI-driven results (Google’s SGE, ChatGPT, Perplexity) give users answers without clicking links.
LinkedIn is the bright spot, with higher engagement and reach (~12%), especially for personal brands.
YouTube & Podcasts are still strong for organic growth, but require long-term commitment and consistency.
Bottom Line: Organic is still viable, but it’s a long game that requires consistency, patience, and repurposing across multiple channels.
3️⃣ The Hard Numbers: What’s It Actually Costing in 2025? (Reality Check on Paid Performance)
Average Cost Per Lead (CPL)
Google Ads: $53 (average across industries)
Facebook Ads: $19.68
LinkedIn Ads: $75+
TikTok Ads: $10–$25
Cost Per Webinar Registrant
Google Ads: $55–$120
Facebook Ads: $30–$80
LinkedIn Ads: $75–$200
TikTok Ads: $20–$50
Cost Per Booked Call
Facebook Ads: $150–$350+ (B2B offers, coaching, high-ticket services)
Google Ads: $300–$1,200 (law firms, finance, specialized industries)
LinkedIn Ads: $500+ per booked call (high-level B2B services)
E-Commerce ROAS (Return on Ad Spend)
Google Shopping: 2.3x–4.1x
Facebook/Instagram: 1.5x–3x
TikTok Ads: 2x–5x (for some brands, still a gold rush)
Amazon Ads: 4x–6x, but Amazon fees eat up a lot of margin
Bottom Line: Paid ads work — but they require deep pockets, strong margins, and ongoing testing to stay profitable.
4️⃣ What Organic Really Takes (No, Posting Once a Week Won’t Cut It)
Content Volume Needed to Win (Per Week):
Twitter/X: 3–5 posts per day
LinkedIn: 5–7 posts per week (text and carousel posts work best)
Instagram: 3–5 feed posts, 5+ stories per day
TikTok: 1–3 posts per day
YouTube: 1 video per week minimum (preferably 2–3)
SEO Blogging: 2–4 high-quality posts per month
Time Required to See Results
SEO: 6–12 months
LinkedIn Authority Growth: 3–6 months
YouTube Growth: 9–18 months
Organic Social (TikTok, Instagram, Twitter/X): 3–6 months if posting daily
Luck vs. Strategy?
Yes, virality helps — but consistency wins long-term.
The brands killing it organically aren’t posting randomly — they have systems, repurposing strategies, and consistent hooks.
Bottom Line: Organic can work — but it’s grueling, takes long-term effort, and only rewards those willing to play the game relentlessly.
At A Glance:
Category | Paid | Organic |
|---|---|---|
Speed of Results | Immediate | Slow & Steady |
Cost | High (e.g., Google Ads CPC averages $2.69) | Low (but labor-intensive) |
Sustainability | Stops when ad spend stops | Builds long-term brand authority |
Return on Investment (ROI) | Average of $2 revenue for every $1 spent | SEO traffic is 5.66 times more cost-effective than paid search |
Scalability | Highly scalable (budget-dependent) | Harder to scale, requires consistent effort |
Targeting | Precise audience targeting | Relies on SEO & engagement, less control |
Trust & Credibility | Consumers skeptical of ads | Builds trust over time |
Competition | Extremely competitive, bidding wars | Competitive, but rewards expertise |
Algorithm Dependence | Subject to ad platform policies | SEO & social algorithms change constantly |
Best For... | Short-term campaigns, lead gen, fast ROI | Long-term authority, brand loyalty, compounding growth |
💡 Key Takeaways from the War Room
Paid Ads offer speed, scale, and direct ROI, but costs are rising across the board — Facebook, Google, and TikTok are all seeing higher CPCs and CPMs in 2025.
Organic is still powerful but takes time and consistency. The days of easy reach are long gone. The average brand needs a bajillion posts per week to see results.
A clear trend? Paid is getting more expensive, but organic is getting harder. Choosing the right path means knowing what you’re really up against.
🚀 The Verdict? There’s No Easy Answer.
If you’re sitting on the sidelines waiting for a “cheap” way to grow, you might be in for a rude awakening.
Both paid and organic require investment — cash, content, or time.
The real question isn’t which is better, but which one is right for you — and do you have the strategy to execute?
🔔 Next Up in Strategy Wars: We reveal the best real-world case studies of brands winning in 2025 — both with paid and organic.
Vote for your favorite below and stay tuned.
💰 Who gets you the best leads in 2025?The marketing battlefield is set. Will Paid Advertising continue to dominate with its instant reach, laser-focused targeting, and scalable ROI? Or will Organic Growth prove its worth with long-term brand loyalty, authenticity, and zero ad spend? |
🎯 FINAL STRATEGIC MOVE
Want To Go Deeper? Here’s How:
1️⃣ The Path — Join our free strategy & coaching group to sharpen your marketing, scale your business, and outmaneuver the competition.
2️⃣ Need a Marketing Playbook — Fast? Book a one-off consultation or bring me in as your Fractional CMO for high-impact, no-BS growth strategies.
3️⃣ Rebrand Like a Billion-Dollar Company. Need a fresh look? We offer done-for-you branding & rebranding services so you can dominate your market.
See you Friday with the battle breakdown. Until then — adapt, strategize, and conquer.
⚔️ Stephen
The Obsessed Strategist
How did you like today's newsletter? |